Magic Bullets and Magic Loogies
SUBJECTIVE
I’m on the second leg of a trip home from Indianapolis. Should land in about 30-45 minutes. I’ll be glad to be home. I went to a very good and informative course on the ASTYM system. I sat and completed it’s certification. It’s a different type of manual therapy designed to introduce irritation to an area to allow for healing of the tissues. Much like the way a vaccination helps prevent the flu, or chicken pox, or polio. The idea behind the system is very neat. In my opinion, there are very few new ideas in physical therapy. It’s all renewed interest in old ideas and a change of presentation. But this….this was new. The potential, in theory, is very neat. The ASTYM people were quick to point out that this treatment philosophy was not a stand along procedure. It was meant to be performed alongside other treatments, especially exercise. Orthopedically speaking: one thing is not going to get any one person better. Healing does not occur in isolation.
OBJECTIVE
One of my favorite episodes of Seinfeld is the Keith Hernandez episode. Before he sold Just For Men, he did a bit role in the early 90s on Seinfeld as a new friend of Jerry. They did a few things together: movies, dinner, and such. But Keith asked Jerry to help him move. That’s a big thing between guys. The only friend I’ve ever asked to help me move was my best friend and we’d known each other 20 years before I was comfortable enough to ask him to do that. Anyway, Kramer and Newman didn’t like Keith Hernendez because of an incident after a Mets game. They were under the impression that Keith hocked a loogie at them after harassing him because of his performance in a baseball game. Jerry maintained –and demonstrated– playing from the Oliver Stone JFK movie, that there was no way Hernendez spit a loogie that hit both of them, as the loogie would have had to made a 90 degree turn in mid-air. Jerry’s final statement, “That’s one magic loogie.”
Many therapists out there purport to have a magic loogie. It doesn’t exist. Each condition that is appropriate for physical therapy, requires, at the very least, some form of exercise (whether it be strengthening or stretching) and some type of hand’s-on therapy.
ASSESSMENT:
Evidenced based practice shows that these are the only two things (manual therapy and exercise) cause lasting effect. I’ve got lots of things that make you feel better. I’ve got a bag of tricks that will work on virtually every condition that walks in the door. Heat, electrical stimulation, and other modalities are like the spice rack in your kitchen: a soup is soup but the addition of salt and pepper makes it all go down nicer. The modalities aid in helping make the treatment more effective but they don’t cause lasting change.
PLAN
The appropriate amount of exercise and manual therapy will get you there. But that exercise program….you have to keep doing it. For the rest of your life? I don’t know. You need to keep doing it for a while. The ASTYM system that I learned about this weekend, I’ll work it into my practice, but it won’t be the sole thing on which I base anyone’s treatment. Remember there’s no magic loogie.




